Review Process

A Review Process is a systematic process that conducts structured evaluation (to assess quality, compliance, and performance of target elements).

• AKA: Assessment Process, Evaluation Process, Review Methodology.
• Context:
  • It can typically be composed of Review Tasks.
  • It can be supported by Review-Supporting Systems.
  • It can typically initiate Review Cycle through submission screening.
  • It can typically assign Review Team through expertise matching.
  • It can typically evaluate Review Material through assessment criteria.
  • It can typically ensure Quality Control through multiple reviewer approach.
  • It can typically track Review Progress through timeline management.
  • ...
  • It can often validate Submission Requirement through initial screening.
  • It can often coordinate Reviewer Assignment through expertise database.
  • It can often manage Review Timeline through scheduling system.
  • It can often document Review Finding through structured feedback.
  • It can often facilitate Decision Making through consensus building.
  • ...
  • It can range from being a Single Reviewer Process to being a Multi-Reviewer Assessment System, depending on its reviewer count.
  • It can range from being a Quick Review Cycle to being an Extended Review Process, depending on its timeline requirement.
  • It can range from being a Basic Screening Process to being a Comprehensive Evaluation System, depending on its assessment depth.
  • It can range from being a Direct Decision Process to being a Multi-Stage Review Cycle, depending on its decision complexity.
  • ...
  • It can establish Review Criteria for quality assessment.
  • It can maintain Review Documentation for process tracking.
  • It can support Revision Cycle for quality improvement.
  • ...
• Examples:
  • Review Stage Processes, such as:
    • Initial Review Stage Processes, such as:
      • First-Pass Review Process for ...
      • Submission Review Screening Process for requirement review validation.
      • Preliminary Review Process for basic review assessment.
    • Review Assignment Processes, such as:
      • Review Expert Matching Process for reviewer selection process.
      • Review Workload Distribution Process for review assignment process.
  • Review Evaluation Processes, such as:
    • Technical Review Assessment Processes, such as:
      • Methodology Review Process for technical review validation.
      • Content Review Process for quality review verification.
    • Impact Review Assessment Processes, such as:
      • Originality Review Process for innovation review assessment.
      • Significance Review Process for impact review assessment.
  • Review Decision Processes, such as:
    • Review Outcome Processes, such as:
      • Direct Review Acceptance Process for review approval process.
      • Review Revision Request Process for improvement review process.
    • Post-Review Processes, such as:
      • Revision Review Process for change review verification.
      • Final Review Decision Process for outcome review determination.
  • Review Quality Control Processes, such as:
    • Review Standard Processes, such as:
      • Multiple Reviewer Review Process for review fairness assurance.
      • Structured Review Feedback Process for review evaluation consistency.
  • ...
• Counter-Examples:
  • Random Check, which lacks systematic approach and structured methodology.
  • Casual Observation, which lacks formal evaluation criteria and documented process.
  • Automated Monitoring, which performs continuous tracking rather than structured review.
• See: Evaluation System, Assessment Methodology, Quality Control Process, Inspection Process.

---